HIM AGAIN: Chapter 11: Moving On - Prejudice
Minerva looked up as Professor Read and the wayward student entered. Around her, the portraits mimed sleep, snoring convincingly - but ever ready to listen in and get a piece of the gossip. Doubtlessly after Brian Potter had left, either Dippet or Nigellus would insist on airing their opinions on the child.
She glanced at the essay, sat ready on her desk, and nodded at Professor Read to leave. There was no point in becoming any more irritated than was necessary. Nevertheless, cheating was a serious matter, and the purpose of the interview was impress upon Brian the need for honesty in the future. Once the door had closed she looked up at the boy himself, to see what impression being summoned to the Headmistress’s office was making on him.
The child’s face was deathly pale and his blue eyes were wide; he was standing as far away from the desk as possible, seemingly transfixed by the sight of her. Minerva was put in the mind of shocked and terrified mouse being hynotised by a snake. Surely she wasn’t all that frightening?
The urge to soften the blow came to her and she frowned at the impulse. There was no sense in being gentle now if it simply resulted in Brian’s expulsion if he cheated at his OWLs. The problem had to be nipped in the bud.
“Mr Potter, please sit down,” she said crisply, fixing him with a disapproving glare.
Brian gaped at her, and she found herself thinking how dissimilar to his parents he was - and yet, how familiar his eyes seemed. He walked across the room and sat himself in the chair slowly, and ripped his face away from Minerva’s, turning it to his lap.
“Mr Potter, are you aware of why you have been summoned here today?”
The boy shook his head, his half-moon spectacles almost falling off. Minerva blinked; the glasses were an odd choice for an eleven-year-old.
“I think you are.”
He looked up and gave her a searching look with his sapphire eyes. She waited but he was apparently unable to speak, so she continued.
“Brian Potter, I would like to impress on you-” She stopped, suddenly remembering exactly who the boy was named after. What would He have thought, she thought bitterly, if He had known that the boy named after Him would turn out to be deceitful? Anger sharpened her words. “I would like to impress on you the seriousness of cheating at Hogwarts. We do not tolerate such deceit here.”
The boy stared at her insolently; he was obviously still pretending ignorance. Minerva felt her nostrils flare in irritation, and she picked up the essay and waved it at him.
“I want you to tell me whom or what you copied - for there is little doubt, Mr Potter, that you have copied. Trying to pass other people’s work as your own qualifies as theft. I am deeply shocked and disappointed in this behaviour, and further attempts to cheat will result in me contacting your parents.”
The child’s face suddenly sagged in horror as he gazed at the essay. Minerva gazed at him coldly; he had been found out, the lie had been unearthed.
“What do you have to say for yourself?”
“I - I-” the student gulped.
“Yes?”
“I’m sorry, M-Professor.”
The Headmistress blinked and narrowed her eyes. M-Professor? Had the boy just been impertinent enough to try and address her by her name? A fire roared into life in her chest.
“Mr Potter,” she found herself whispering. “I will not suffer this impudence.”
His silence infuriated her.
“Explain yourself.”
Brian’s mouth worked. Then-
“I apologise, Professor. It won’t happen again,” he said smoothly.
Minerva stood up. Students who did wrong and denied it when caught were bad enough, but students like the one before her - who at first pretended ignorance and then apologised so slickly, insincerely - were beyond the pale. The boy was nothing like his parents, she thought fiercely, nothing at all. This was a reborn Draco Malfoy at the peak of his insolence and disregard for authority - that the child she had once held in her arms should turn into this-! She placed her hands at opposite ends of the desk and leaned forward, so that the boy sank back in his chair.
“I’m afraid that more than cursory apologies are needed here! I will not tolerate such lack of respect, Mr Potter! Detention, on Saturday at five o’clock with Mr Filch! Now tell me what source you copied from!”
“I d-didn’t, P-Professor! I honestly s-swear I didn’t copy from a-anything!”
There was something wrong about the stutter, as if the voice’s owner didn’t naturally stutter but had felt it necessary to produce a passable rendition. Minerva felt herself becoming incensed. She stared into the pale, shocked face, suddenly feeling as though the whole display was an act designed to placate her.
“Then I would very much like to know an alternative explanation!” She drew herself up to her full height. “You have blatantly either copied from a book or gotten someone else both older and cleverer than you to write it instead! Provide me with the source or I shall be forced to contact your parents.”
The boy gazed at her silently. His pale cheeks were beginning to flush and the blue eyes begged her not to do anything of the sort, but the pointed jaw remained clamped.
“Very well,” she said quietly. “I’m writing to your parents tonight. You may go. Don’t forget your detention on Saturday.”
He got up from the chair and left the office. As he did so, Minerva was satisfied to see that his small limbs were shaking very slightly. The moment the door closed behind him, the portraits began to mutter as she sat back down at the desk.
“Disgraceful behaviour,” declared Dippet. “Simply shocking.”
“In my day,” said Everard, “he would have been hung upside-down in the dungeons by his ankles and left there for a couple of hours.”
“Well, Headmistress, you certainly had him cowed,” commented Derwent, shaking her painted silver ringlets.
“On the contrary, Dilys,” Minerva stated coldly. “I believe he was considerably less frightened than how he appeared. A cold and calculating student.”
“Doubtlessly just the sort of boy Lestrange would have approved of,” Phineas Nigellus drawled, looking over at the mentioned former headmaster’s portrait only to find it empty. “But then, I never understood Dumbledore’s fixation on the father-”
“-Who has little to do with his son, personality-wise,” interrupted Minerva, irritated. It saddened her that He would most certainly have thought of the boy as a grandson - how disappointed He would have been!
She ripped a sheet of clean parchment from the roll inside the nearest drawer, and dipped a quill into some ink, wondering how to begin chastising the boy to his family. She was about to set point on paper when a small voice broke the overhead clamour.
“I wouldn’t dismiss the boy out of hand if I were you, Headmistress.”
Minerva looked around, at first confused - and then saw the Sorting Hat twitching on its shelf across the office. It was unusual for the hat to speak at all, and the portraits were automatically silenced.
“I saw some very… unusual things in his head. He won’t go through Hogwarts unnoticed, that’s for sure.”
She sniffed and turned back to the parchment. “Unusual, yes, but not desirable.”
Tuesday, February 13, 2007
HA 10d: Student
HIM AGAIN: Chapter 10: Ashes to Ashes - Student
The other boys had already gone down to breakfast by the time Albus woke up the next morning - with the exception of Eric, who had quite obviously waited for him.
“Good morning,” he said cheerily, as Albus washed and donned Brian’s school-robes. “Are you all right now?”
“Sorry?”
“Last night. When you were asleep. It looked like you were having a really weird nightmare.”
“Really?” asked Albus, a small version of himself beginning to jangle the alarm bells.
“Yeah - you went all rigid at one point, and nearly fell out of your bed. It really freaked me out. And you said something, too.”
Albus stared at Eric, desperately keeping the happy expression pasted on Brian’s face. What had he said? Had it been… Minerva? Why - why would his subconscious self want to call that?
Thank me when you’ve sorted your heart out as well as your head.
He knew the answer really. He just didn’t dare think it; the hopelessness of the situation-
“It sounded like ‘Serverus.’ Or ‘Siverus.’ Or ‘Severus.’ Something like that. And you said please to something. Can’t you remember what it was about at all?”
“No,” he blurted - but he felt the blood leave Brian’s face. Snape stood before him again, ignoring his pleas not to turn his back on truth and justice and Lily, raising his wand, face contorted, sending him to his death. The betrayal was like a knife entering his ribcage, coldly penetrating to his beating heart. Poor, damaged, guilt-wracked Severus, whom he’d cared for in a similar way to Harry, had turned into the malignant Snape, merciless and filled with contempt for the man who’d supported him. What had happened, what had he done wrong?
Eric was eyeing him oddly; Albus struggled to get control over his - and Brian’s - face, but the damage was done. Hopefully Eric would simply think it had been a horrific nightmare that Brian didn’t want to talk about, which wasn’t that far from the truth anyway. Neither spoke on the way down to breakfast.
Potions was first. Albus, too moved by the reported nightmare to try at pretences, brewed a perfect Anti-Boil potion that resulted in Slughorn talking fondly of Harry for half the lesson. Really, Albus thought half-indignantly, it wasn’t as if he had ever known Harry all that well. I had the monopoly there. The thought of Harry calmed him, steadied his shaken nerves.
Transfiguration came next, this time punctuated with inexplicably stony glances from Professor Read and convincing failures at simple Transfiguration spells. The advantage of having once been a teacher who had understood where students could go wrong allowed Albus the satisfaction of successfully answering a question incorrectly.
“Your homework is to practice,” Professor Read said reedily. “That is all.”
“Come on,” Eric said, as Albus packed away his bag.
“Brian Potter,” the teacher squawked just as both boys were about to leave the room. “See me. Run along, Mr Weasley.”
Confused, Albus walked up to Professor Read, head bowed in an accurate impersonation of a nervous pupil. Since Professor Read looked like the sort of person to be easily blown away by a strong gust of wind, such anxiety really did have to be feigned.
“Mr Potter. You are to come and see the Headmistress immediately.”
“Why, Professor?”
He was astonished he had managed to speak, to ask such an innocent question. Minerva’s face filled his brain - as it had been, strong and defiant, and as it was, hollow and pale. His body had frozen in shock; here it was, the ultimate test of his will, of his acting abilities, of his heart-
Professor Read looked outraged. “You may find wasting my time amusing, Mr Potter, but I assure you the Headmistress does not! Follow me!”
The corridors passed by like a dream. It occurred to Albus that, ironically, he felt just as any other First-Year would feel having been summoned to the head teacher’s office. His stomach twisted; his tongue stuck to the roof of his mouth. Minerva had found out somehow, had cooked up some excuse for Professor Read to take him to her office, in a few minutes time he would be pouring out the whole story to her…
Then, perhaps, one day he would be able to tell her what he felt. Perhaps he would be able to do so when Brian was a man and Minerva an ailing old woman on her death-bed-
Of course, she would die before him now. That fact was undeniable. It made him want to hurl himself out of the nearest window.
When Brian was a man and Minerva an ailing old woman - surely that would be better than when he was trapped in the body of a child? He couldn’t imagine the saying the words in a child’s voice whilst in a child’s body. The image was wrong. At least, if he told her at the last, then there would be a finality to it. There would be no need for rejections or pain, because she would be gone to her next great adventure…
“Such interesting thoughts you have,” the Sorting Hat said again, but bitterly.
“Ashes to ashes.”
The odd, macabre password was spoken quickly and the gargoyle leapt aside. They were ascending up stairs he still thought of as his own…
The door was before them. Professor Read rapped smartly on the wood, ignore the Griffin knocker. Albus stared at it vaguely, remembering what a terrific joke it had seemed when he’d installed it upon becoming headmaster. Griffin-door. Gryffindor. Now the door had become a portal to more than a joke.
There was an agonising silence, and then a curt reply.
“Enter.”
The other boys had already gone down to breakfast by the time Albus woke up the next morning - with the exception of Eric, who had quite obviously waited for him.
“Good morning,” he said cheerily, as Albus washed and donned Brian’s school-robes. “Are you all right now?”
“Sorry?”
“Last night. When you were asleep. It looked like you were having a really weird nightmare.”
“Really?” asked Albus, a small version of himself beginning to jangle the alarm bells.
“Yeah - you went all rigid at one point, and nearly fell out of your bed. It really freaked me out. And you said something, too.”
Albus stared at Eric, desperately keeping the happy expression pasted on Brian’s face. What had he said? Had it been… Minerva? Why - why would his subconscious self want to call that?
Thank me when you’ve sorted your heart out as well as your head.
He knew the answer really. He just didn’t dare think it; the hopelessness of the situation-
“It sounded like ‘Serverus.’ Or ‘Siverus.’ Or ‘Severus.’ Something like that. And you said please to something. Can’t you remember what it was about at all?”
“No,” he blurted - but he felt the blood leave Brian’s face. Snape stood before him again, ignoring his pleas not to turn his back on truth and justice and Lily, raising his wand, face contorted, sending him to his death. The betrayal was like a knife entering his ribcage, coldly penetrating to his beating heart. Poor, damaged, guilt-wracked Severus, whom he’d cared for in a similar way to Harry, had turned into the malignant Snape, merciless and filled with contempt for the man who’d supported him. What had happened, what had he done wrong?
Eric was eyeing him oddly; Albus struggled to get control over his - and Brian’s - face, but the damage was done. Hopefully Eric would simply think it had been a horrific nightmare that Brian didn’t want to talk about, which wasn’t that far from the truth anyway. Neither spoke on the way down to breakfast.
Potions was first. Albus, too moved by the reported nightmare to try at pretences, brewed a perfect Anti-Boil potion that resulted in Slughorn talking fondly of Harry for half the lesson. Really, Albus thought half-indignantly, it wasn’t as if he had ever known Harry all that well. I had the monopoly there. The thought of Harry calmed him, steadied his shaken nerves.
Transfiguration came next, this time punctuated with inexplicably stony glances from Professor Read and convincing failures at simple Transfiguration spells. The advantage of having once been a teacher who had understood where students could go wrong allowed Albus the satisfaction of successfully answering a question incorrectly.
“Your homework is to practice,” Professor Read said reedily. “That is all.”
“Come on,” Eric said, as Albus packed away his bag.
“Brian Potter,” the teacher squawked just as both boys were about to leave the room. “See me. Run along, Mr Weasley.”
Confused, Albus walked up to Professor Read, head bowed in an accurate impersonation of a nervous pupil. Since Professor Read looked like the sort of person to be easily blown away by a strong gust of wind, such anxiety really did have to be feigned.
“Mr Potter. You are to come and see the Headmistress immediately.”
“Why, Professor?”
He was astonished he had managed to speak, to ask such an innocent question. Minerva’s face filled his brain - as it had been, strong and defiant, and as it was, hollow and pale. His body had frozen in shock; here it was, the ultimate test of his will, of his acting abilities, of his heart-
Professor Read looked outraged. “You may find wasting my time amusing, Mr Potter, but I assure you the Headmistress does not! Follow me!”
The corridors passed by like a dream. It occurred to Albus that, ironically, he felt just as any other First-Year would feel having been summoned to the head teacher’s office. His stomach twisted; his tongue stuck to the roof of his mouth. Minerva had found out somehow, had cooked up some excuse for Professor Read to take him to her office, in a few minutes time he would be pouring out the whole story to her…
Then, perhaps, one day he would be able to tell her what he felt. Perhaps he would be able to do so when Brian was a man and Minerva an ailing old woman on her death-bed-
Of course, she would die before him now. That fact was undeniable. It made him want to hurl himself out of the nearest window.
When Brian was a man and Minerva an ailing old woman - surely that would be better than when he was trapped in the body of a child? He couldn’t imagine the saying the words in a child’s voice whilst in a child’s body. The image was wrong. At least, if he told her at the last, then there would be a finality to it. There would be no need for rejections or pain, because she would be gone to her next great adventure…
“Such interesting thoughts you have,” the Sorting Hat said again, but bitterly.
“Ashes to ashes.”
The odd, macabre password was spoken quickly and the gargoyle leapt aside. They were ascending up stairs he still thought of as his own…
The door was before them. Professor Read rapped smartly on the wood, ignore the Griffin knocker. Albus stared at it vaguely, remembering what a terrific joke it had seemed when he’d installed it upon becoming headmaster. Griffin-door. Gryffindor. Now the door had become a portal to more than a joke.
There was an agonising silence, and then a curt reply.
“Enter.”
HA 10c: Liar
HIM AGAIN: Chapter 10: Ashes to Ashes - Liar
It was late, and Minerva’s body was beginning to protest as she dragged it up the stairs to her office - yet there was still the matter of Professor Read’s ‘genius’ essay to attend to. Seeing it lying on the desk where she‘d abandoned it earlier, she eyed it distastefully.
Prejudice again, someone in her head pointed out. You don’t want to read it because Read loved it.
She nodded to herself, accepting the charge. There was something so profoundly irritating about Martha that it coloured everything she touched or approved of - the essay, the embodiment of all things inanimate and harmless, seemed to exude a fussy, melodramatic air that made her want to throw it in the bin. Nevertheless, reading it would only take a few minutes, and Martha was bound to mention it the next day so there was no excuse to put it off.
Easing herself into the chair, Minerva found herself struck by the handwriting - loopy and distinctive, somehow old-fashioned and quaint. For a moment, she gazed at it. There was an aura of familiarity about it; something she couldn’t put her finger on. She shook herself and began to read: she had never read Brian Potter’s handwriting before and there was no logical reason for it to be familiar.
Fifteen minutes passed. Scepticism gave way to astonishment, astonishment to awe, awe to vague annoyance. She set the essay back down on the table and stared out of the window distractedly.
The style was impressive, far beyond the standard of most Seventh-Years. Complicated technical terms littered the text and the subject was analysed in a depth Minerva knew the that even Transfiguration teacher-training board did not expect. Martha had been right - this sort of thing belonged in an international professional journal, not in a First-Year’s first essay. The mind who had written this was brilliant, with their knowledge standing beyond even her own, excelling her in reasoned speculation and theory. In fact, Minerva felt herself desiring to meet with the writer and have a good intellectual discussion about some of the issues they’d raised.
The name at the top of the parchment stood out at her again. Brian Potter.
She sighed and sat back. There was no doubt about it: the boy had either copied and not had the sense to copy something average and mediocre, or he had somehow persuaded a professional to write it. She fancied that there was something familiar about the style; perhaps she had read the work of the same writer in a book somewhere?
A disappointing, Slytherin-ish thing for the son of Harry and Ginny Potter to have done, she thought. Then fury fired her mind. Could she not suppress the prejudice? Would she always be looking for ways to think well of the children of her friends?
Trying to calm herself, Minerva got up and walked into her chambers, straight up to the bookcase. Stimulated by a First-Year essay, she took down a book and began to read, exhaustion forgotten.
It was late, and Minerva’s body was beginning to protest as she dragged it up the stairs to her office - yet there was still the matter of Professor Read’s ‘genius’ essay to attend to. Seeing it lying on the desk where she‘d abandoned it earlier, she eyed it distastefully.
Prejudice again, someone in her head pointed out. You don’t want to read it because Read loved it.
She nodded to herself, accepting the charge. There was something so profoundly irritating about Martha that it coloured everything she touched or approved of - the essay, the embodiment of all things inanimate and harmless, seemed to exude a fussy, melodramatic air that made her want to throw it in the bin. Nevertheless, reading it would only take a few minutes, and Martha was bound to mention it the next day so there was no excuse to put it off.
Easing herself into the chair, Minerva found herself struck by the handwriting - loopy and distinctive, somehow old-fashioned and quaint. For a moment, she gazed at it. There was an aura of familiarity about it; something she couldn’t put her finger on. She shook herself and began to read: she had never read Brian Potter’s handwriting before and there was no logical reason for it to be familiar.
Fifteen minutes passed. Scepticism gave way to astonishment, astonishment to awe, awe to vague annoyance. She set the essay back down on the table and stared out of the window distractedly.
The style was impressive, far beyond the standard of most Seventh-Years. Complicated technical terms littered the text and the subject was analysed in a depth Minerva knew the that even Transfiguration teacher-training board did not expect. Martha had been right - this sort of thing belonged in an international professional journal, not in a First-Year’s first essay. The mind who had written this was brilliant, with their knowledge standing beyond even her own, excelling her in reasoned speculation and theory. In fact, Minerva felt herself desiring to meet with the writer and have a good intellectual discussion about some of the issues they’d raised.
The name at the top of the parchment stood out at her again. Brian Potter.
She sighed and sat back. There was no doubt about it: the boy had either copied and not had the sense to copy something average and mediocre, or he had somehow persuaded a professional to write it. She fancied that there was something familiar about the style; perhaps she had read the work of the same writer in a book somewhere?
A disappointing, Slytherin-ish thing for the son of Harry and Ginny Potter to have done, she thought. Then fury fired her mind. Could she not suppress the prejudice? Would she always be looking for ways to think well of the children of her friends?
Trying to calm herself, Minerva got up and walked into her chambers, straight up to the bookcase. Stimulated by a First-Year essay, she took down a book and began to read, exhaustion forgotten.
HA 10b: Outcast
HIM AGAIN: Chapter 10: Ashes to Ashes - Outcast
“Lights out!”
Abigail Lupin was stomping around the Gryffindor dormitories, glaring at those who weren’t yet in bed. Albus had had to suppress a knowing chuckle more than once; Abigail seemed to have inherited both her father’s sense and her mother’s forthrightness - when one Second-Year had refused to give up his chair in the Common Room, she had simply grabbed him by one ear and pulled him up to his dormitory whilst using her Metamorphmagi abilities to pull threatening faces.
“You, what are you sniggering at?” she demanded, staring at him as he began to draw the bed-hangings closed.
“Nothing,” he said politely, suppressing a smile.
“Right then. Nox.”
The dormitory dimmed and there was a brief silence in the first few minutes after the Head Girl had exited. Then the First-Years, the excitement of sleeping away from home having not quite worn off, began to whisper and giggle, sitting up and drawing back their bed-hangings. Albus drew back his own too; if he was going to relive life as a student there was no point in being stand-offish.
The other four boys in his dormitory were already chatting and laughing. His eyes moved to their faces one by one, knowing that his observation was unlikely to be interrupted. Stand-offish he tried not to be, but his lack of confidence in accurately portraying an eleven-year-old to actual eleven-year-olds and his awareness of being much older and inevitably cleverer had led to a good deal of silence on his part. That accompanied with awkward smiles and one word replies had soon given his classmates the impression that he wanted to be left alone, just four days into the term.
The first boy Albus’s eyes found was Eric Weasley, the loud and humorous third child of Bill and Fleur. His young face was already very like Bill’s, and Albus was certain that the coming years would leave a mark on the Hogwarts female population. He also happened to be Brian's cousin, and was the subject of an unspoken war between Molly and Fleur; Molly welcomed him into the bosom of the Weasley family, whilst Fleur firmly dragged him away to the Delacours, with the result that alone out of the Weasley clan, Eric and his siblings were perfect strangers to Brian. Unsurprisingly, Eric, out of all the Gryffindor boys, had been the most persistent in trying to make friends with him, chattering away at him in Potions until even a very genial Slughorn had wagged a warning finger at their table. Family connection notwithstanding, Albus suspected that it was something to do with the fact that both Brian and Eric was children of figures of the Second War and, as such, both had to deal with unwanted media attention.
The second boy, Mark Scott, had taken Albus’s reticence as a sign of vanity and now tended to pointedly ignore him whenever he was in the same room. Mark also talked with the air of pretending to know more than he actually did; the Scott family patriarch’s opinions could be heard in every word. The third, Daniel Glover, seemed to fall easily into the role of Eric’s hero-worshipper (“I can’t believe you can fly like that! I can’t believe anyone can fly like that!”) and the fourth, Cal Smith, was painfully shy, adopting an ingratiating manner every time someone spoke to him (“Really? Yes! I thought that too!”).
“…And Madam Hooch said she was going to speak to Professor McGonagall about it,” Eric was saying triumphantly.
“Wicked!” said Daniel, beaming. “I bet she lets you, too! You’ll be the second youngest on the team in over a century!”
“Wasn’t the first your dad?” Eric said suddenly, looking over at Brian.
“Yes,” said Albus, injecting some hesitation into Brian’s voice so as to reinforce the impression of shyness.
“What position did he play?” asked Daniel.
“Seeker, of course!” Eric replied, rolling his eyes. “Madam Hooch talked about him for half the lesson!”
“And then she spent the other half of the lesson talking about you,” Mark pointed out.
Erin flushed. “Yeah, well - Brian wasn’t bad either. Had you flown before?” he asked, addressing him again.
“Yes,” said Albus easily. For one thing, it was the truth - Harry had often taken Brian flying on his old Firebolt, allowing for some ability to be displayed in class.
“He wasn’t bad,” said Mark. “But he was nothing like you, Eric. Did you see Madam Hooch’s face? She thought he was going to be like his dad and he wasn’t-!”
“He was still good,” Eric interrupted, shooting Albus an encouraging smile. “And he’s in the best in the class at every lesson.”
“Not really,” protested Albus, knowing that most normal eleven-year-olds would object to that. “I wasn’t really.”
“Yes you were! You got everything right first time in Charms - and in Transfiguration - and in Herbology!”
Albus had to suppress a sigh. Every time he walked into a classroom he resolved to make deliberate mistakes, to be slow at learning, to pretend to get confused. Unfortunately, the resolution was usually forgotten whenever the situation presented itself, and whenever it was remembered, it proved almost impossible to fulfil. Performing spells that were second-nature wrongly was incredibly difficult and took far more concentration than was required to cast the spells in the first place. He’d managed to set his feather on fire in Charms, but only after levitating it almost to the ceiling and he‘d contrived to add the wrong ingredients in Potions, leading to a short scolding from Slughorn, but the mistake seemed too obvious to be repeated too many times. The worst crises had been in the first few lessons of Transfiguration - during which he had struggled to simplify his answers to questions and had had to repress the urge to clarify the inept teacher on certain points. All in all, it was exhausting.
“So, what do you all think of the teachers so far?” he asked, trying to make conversation. He winced; the question sounded just the sort of thing the Hogwarts Headmaster would ask if secretly disguised as a student - as he was now.
“Dunno, really.” Eric shrugged. “Slughorn’s funny, even if he does go on about all the famous people he’s ever known. Sprout’s all right, Binns is boring, Hooch is okay, I suppose… Read’s annoying.”
“Yeah - yeah I thought that,” Cal agreed.
“I tried to run away back to the Common Room today, when she gave us that essay,” Mark muttered.
“Really?” said Eric interestedly. “Didn’t you get into trouble?”
“Obviously - that’s why I still turned up, but late. McGonagall caught me in the corridors.”
Albus felt his attention sharpen to a point. Minerva! Why had he not tried to bunk off too so as to meet her, even if only for a scolding? The other boys also sat up - but for a different reason.
“What’s she like?” Daniel asked. “I mean, we only ever see her at breakfast and dinner-”
Mark shrugged. “Strict and stern. She all pursed her lips at me and acted as though I’d tried to throw someone out the window or something.” He put on a high, squeaky voice that Albus didn’t think sounded at all like Minerva’s. “‘Mr Scott, is it? Why are you not in your lessons? Run along immediately or I shall inform your Head of House.’”
Both Daniel and Eric laughed - and Albus found himself liking the latter less. “She looks ill, doesn’t she?” the former commented.
“Yes. I asked someone about that - one of the Fifth-Years about whether she was suffering from some lethal wasting disease and was about to drop down dead. They got well annoyed and bit my head off - but they said she’s always looked like that! And that, actually, she’s gotten better!”
“My dad said something about her getting hurt in the war,” Eric murmured. “It’s probably to do with that.”
Albus found himself sitting on the edge of his bed, as though nearness could affect the amount of information received. Minerva… getting hurt. But how? What had happened? Or had Bill simply been talking about her encounter with Umbridge and her Stunners?
“What happened?” he asked breathlessly.
Eric gave him a blank look whilst Mark raised one eyebrow. “I dunno. Dad didn’t say.”
Daniel yawned. “I’m turning in now. That Flying lesson really tired me out.”
“Oh all right then.”
The First-Years settled back down in their beds. Albus laid down with his back to the other boys and his face to the cold chill of the window. Through it, he could see the dark spire of the Astronomy Tower rising up against the moon. As though from a long way away, he again saw himself falling, with the ghostly light of the Dark Mark shining up above. How ridiculous it must have looked, he thought distantly. His beard and robes would have been all flapping in the wind - and Merlin knew what his body must have looked like.
“I was the one who found his - his body…” Harry said softly, staring over the baby Brian’s head at a past both dark and horrible.
Poor Harry, he thought. On top of everything else, he shouldn’t have had to find that.
“He’s weird,” he heard Mark whisper.
“Who?” Daniel whispered back.
“Potter. Too high and mighty to talk properly.”
“He was a bit funny about McGonagall.”
“He’s bit funny about everything.”
“Shush,” said Eric.
“Lights out!”
Abigail Lupin was stomping around the Gryffindor dormitories, glaring at those who weren’t yet in bed. Albus had had to suppress a knowing chuckle more than once; Abigail seemed to have inherited both her father’s sense and her mother’s forthrightness - when one Second-Year had refused to give up his chair in the Common Room, she had simply grabbed him by one ear and pulled him up to his dormitory whilst using her Metamorphmagi abilities to pull threatening faces.
“You, what are you sniggering at?” she demanded, staring at him as he began to draw the bed-hangings closed.
“Nothing,” he said politely, suppressing a smile.
“Right then. Nox.”
The dormitory dimmed and there was a brief silence in the first few minutes after the Head Girl had exited. Then the First-Years, the excitement of sleeping away from home having not quite worn off, began to whisper and giggle, sitting up and drawing back their bed-hangings. Albus drew back his own too; if he was going to relive life as a student there was no point in being stand-offish.
The other four boys in his dormitory were already chatting and laughing. His eyes moved to their faces one by one, knowing that his observation was unlikely to be interrupted. Stand-offish he tried not to be, but his lack of confidence in accurately portraying an eleven-year-old to actual eleven-year-olds and his awareness of being much older and inevitably cleverer had led to a good deal of silence on his part. That accompanied with awkward smiles and one word replies had soon given his classmates the impression that he wanted to be left alone, just four days into the term.
The first boy Albus’s eyes found was Eric Weasley, the loud and humorous third child of Bill and Fleur. His young face was already very like Bill’s, and Albus was certain that the coming years would leave a mark on the Hogwarts female population. He also happened to be Brian's cousin, and was the subject of an unspoken war between Molly and Fleur; Molly welcomed him into the bosom of the Weasley family, whilst Fleur firmly dragged him away to the Delacours, with the result that alone out of the Weasley clan, Eric and his siblings were perfect strangers to Brian. Unsurprisingly, Eric, out of all the Gryffindor boys, had been the most persistent in trying to make friends with him, chattering away at him in Potions until even a very genial Slughorn had wagged a warning finger at their table. Family connection notwithstanding, Albus suspected that it was something to do with the fact that both Brian and Eric was children of figures of the Second War and, as such, both had to deal with unwanted media attention.
The second boy, Mark Scott, had taken Albus’s reticence as a sign of vanity and now tended to pointedly ignore him whenever he was in the same room. Mark also talked with the air of pretending to know more than he actually did; the Scott family patriarch’s opinions could be heard in every word. The third, Daniel Glover, seemed to fall easily into the role of Eric’s hero-worshipper (“I can’t believe you can fly like that! I can’t believe anyone can fly like that!”) and the fourth, Cal Smith, was painfully shy, adopting an ingratiating manner every time someone spoke to him (“Really? Yes! I thought that too!”).
“…And Madam Hooch said she was going to speak to Professor McGonagall about it,” Eric was saying triumphantly.
“Wicked!” said Daniel, beaming. “I bet she lets you, too! You’ll be the second youngest on the team in over a century!”
“Wasn’t the first your dad?” Eric said suddenly, looking over at Brian.
“Yes,” said Albus, injecting some hesitation into Brian’s voice so as to reinforce the impression of shyness.
“What position did he play?” asked Daniel.
“Seeker, of course!” Eric replied, rolling his eyes. “Madam Hooch talked about him for half the lesson!”
“And then she spent the other half of the lesson talking about you,” Mark pointed out.
Erin flushed. “Yeah, well - Brian wasn’t bad either. Had you flown before?” he asked, addressing him again.
“Yes,” said Albus easily. For one thing, it was the truth - Harry had often taken Brian flying on his old Firebolt, allowing for some ability to be displayed in class.
“He wasn’t bad,” said Mark. “But he was nothing like you, Eric. Did you see Madam Hooch’s face? She thought he was going to be like his dad and he wasn’t-!”
“He was still good,” Eric interrupted, shooting Albus an encouraging smile. “And he’s in the best in the class at every lesson.”
“Not really,” protested Albus, knowing that most normal eleven-year-olds would object to that. “I wasn’t really.”
“Yes you were! You got everything right first time in Charms - and in Transfiguration - and in Herbology!”
Albus had to suppress a sigh. Every time he walked into a classroom he resolved to make deliberate mistakes, to be slow at learning, to pretend to get confused. Unfortunately, the resolution was usually forgotten whenever the situation presented itself, and whenever it was remembered, it proved almost impossible to fulfil. Performing spells that were second-nature wrongly was incredibly difficult and took far more concentration than was required to cast the spells in the first place. He’d managed to set his feather on fire in Charms, but only after levitating it almost to the ceiling and he‘d contrived to add the wrong ingredients in Potions, leading to a short scolding from Slughorn, but the mistake seemed too obvious to be repeated too many times. The worst crises had been in the first few lessons of Transfiguration - during which he had struggled to simplify his answers to questions and had had to repress the urge to clarify the inept teacher on certain points. All in all, it was exhausting.
“So, what do you all think of the teachers so far?” he asked, trying to make conversation. He winced; the question sounded just the sort of thing the Hogwarts Headmaster would ask if secretly disguised as a student - as he was now.
“Dunno, really.” Eric shrugged. “Slughorn’s funny, even if he does go on about all the famous people he’s ever known. Sprout’s all right, Binns is boring, Hooch is okay, I suppose… Read’s annoying.”
“Yeah - yeah I thought that,” Cal agreed.
“I tried to run away back to the Common Room today, when she gave us that essay,” Mark muttered.
“Really?” said Eric interestedly. “Didn’t you get into trouble?”
“Obviously - that’s why I still turned up, but late. McGonagall caught me in the corridors.”
Albus felt his attention sharpen to a point. Minerva! Why had he not tried to bunk off too so as to meet her, even if only for a scolding? The other boys also sat up - but for a different reason.
“What’s she like?” Daniel asked. “I mean, we only ever see her at breakfast and dinner-”
Mark shrugged. “Strict and stern. She all pursed her lips at me and acted as though I’d tried to throw someone out the window or something.” He put on a high, squeaky voice that Albus didn’t think sounded at all like Minerva’s. “‘Mr Scott, is it? Why are you not in your lessons? Run along immediately or I shall inform your Head of House.’”
Both Daniel and Eric laughed - and Albus found himself liking the latter less. “She looks ill, doesn’t she?” the former commented.
“Yes. I asked someone about that - one of the Fifth-Years about whether she was suffering from some lethal wasting disease and was about to drop down dead. They got well annoyed and bit my head off - but they said she’s always looked like that! And that, actually, she’s gotten better!”
“My dad said something about her getting hurt in the war,” Eric murmured. “It’s probably to do with that.”
Albus found himself sitting on the edge of his bed, as though nearness could affect the amount of information received. Minerva… getting hurt. But how? What had happened? Or had Bill simply been talking about her encounter with Umbridge and her Stunners?
“What happened?” he asked breathlessly.
Eric gave him a blank look whilst Mark raised one eyebrow. “I dunno. Dad didn’t say.”
Daniel yawned. “I’m turning in now. That Flying lesson really tired me out.”
“Oh all right then.”
The First-Years settled back down in their beds. Albus laid down with his back to the other boys and his face to the cold chill of the window. Through it, he could see the dark spire of the Astronomy Tower rising up against the moon. As though from a long way away, he again saw himself falling, with the ghostly light of the Dark Mark shining up above. How ridiculous it must have looked, he thought distantly. His beard and robes would have been all flapping in the wind - and Merlin knew what his body must have looked like.
“I was the one who found his - his body…” Harry said softly, staring over the baby Brian’s head at a past both dark and horrible.
Poor Harry, he thought. On top of everything else, he shouldn’t have had to find that.
“He’s weird,” he heard Mark whisper.
“Who?” Daniel whispered back.
“Potter. Too high and mighty to talk properly.”
“He was a bit funny about McGonagall.”
“He’s bit funny about everything.”
“Shush,” said Eric.
HA 10a: Genius
HIM AGAIN: Chapter 10: Ashes to Ashes - Genius
A mere four days into the new school year - and already, there had been trouble.
A bad sign, Minerva thought wearily as she made her way up to the staff room. It certainly did not bode well for the rest of the year when it had taken just two days for three students to be found wandering around the Forbidden Forest by Hagrid - Sixth-Years, no less, who should have known better. Then there had been the recent spat of trouble between Slughorn and Pomona - with the latter claiming that the former had ‘mutilated her prize Tentacula with the base intention of procuring venom for his wretched potions.’ Sybil Trelawney had yet again marched into Minerva’s office to demand Firenze’s immediate ejection from the castle, with the result that the Headmistress had felt very much like ejecting Sybil from the castle. To cap it all, Professor Read, the new Transfiguration teacher, had stubbornly set the First-Years an essay that was quite beyond their capabilities despite multiple objections.
She shook her head; surely it wasn’t all that bad? The Sixth-Years had been unharmed, with the lies simply extending to the idea of ‘some man in the woods’ they’d apparently followed, the prize Tantacula was hardly ‘mutilated’ and Sybil was as a permanent a problem as the drainage; one had to accept it and move on. As for Professor Read - there was no doubt that her own prejudices were interfering there. Perhaps it was because she lived in the past so much, but Professor Read would always be ‘new’ - and what’s more, a usurper of her position. Minerva wondered whether Albus had felt the same when she’d taken over Transfiguration; she hoped not.
The staff room was ominously silent when she entered. Pomona was fuming darkly in an armchair by the fire, a book entitled Repairing Herbological Damage perched conspicuously on her knee, and Slughorn was red in the face and seemed inflated even more than usual by an air of injured self-importance. The room still seemed to echo from the sounds of a heated argument. Trelawney gave an obvious sniff at Minerva’s entry and went back to her marking with a look that said: That woman. She’ll never understand me, the poor abused Seer…
The Headmistress shot her a glare and made her way over the sofa where Rolanda sat. She rarely entered the staff room but when she did, it was usually to see the flying instructor. Rolanda had mumbled something at breakfast about one of the First-Years ‘being uncommonly good on a broom - and the rule was broken once before…’
“Minerva!” said Rolanda, noticing her presence only she sat down next to her. “Glad you’re here - the atmosphere here is terrible-”
“Yes, isn’t it?” said Pomona loudly. “But then, vandalism has never been welcome here at Hogwarts-”
Slughorn mouthed incoherently at the back of the Herbology professor’s head. “These accusations are completely unfounded! My good woman-”
“I am not your good woman, Professor Slughorn,” replied Pomona coldly. “If you needed ingredients, you simply had to ask-”
“I did! Several times! But to suggest that I-”
“And each time, I believe I informed you that it had not yet matured sufficiently-”
“Preposterous! Tentacula venom doesn’t need to mature-”
“Headmistress,” Pomona said sharply. “Professor Slughorn has admitted-”
“Admitted? I have admitted nothing! First you supply me with inaccurate information and then you accuse me-”
Rolanda rolled her eyes and gently put a hand on Minerva‘s shoulder to stop her from standing up to interfere. “Oh ignore them, they’ve been at it all evening.” She leaned forward suddenly, with a serious, excited look.
“Rolanda, if this is about the First-Year-” Minerva began, deciding to stem the adulation before it got out of hand.
To her astonishment, Rolanda waved her hand airily as though batting away a fly. “Never mind about Mr Weasley; he can wait. Listen, I was going up to the Owlery and you’d never believe what I saw!”
“What?”
Doubt crept into her friend’s face. “Well - I think that was what I saw - I only glimpsed it, you see, before it flew away-”
“Spit it out, Rolanda.”
The flying instructor was looking more and more anxious with every second. Minerva felt the brown eyes sweep over her, as if a bombshell was about to be dropped and it was arguable as to whether or not the Headmistress could withstand the impact. “Minerva… I’m not sure whether it was his… it looked like his - but I suppose it could have been-”
The sounds of Slughorn and Pomona’s argument cut off, suddenly, as if all the debate had been was a broadcast on a radio that had been turned off. His. Minerva found herself leaning forward. His? As in… His? A pain shafted down the centre of her chest, down the internal scars left by the Stunners of over a decade before. She took a deep breath-
CRASH.
The door rebounded back off the wall, almost smacking back in the freckled face of Professor Read, who shouted something nobody understood, waving a length of parchment in the air. Minerva found herself in her Animagus form, the shock of the Transfiguration teacher’s entry having forced her transformation and set her fur on end.
Embarassed, the Headmistress shifted back, and sent a disapproving glare in Professor Read’s direction. She turned her head back to Rolanda - but the disturber of the peace was now shrieking something, continuing to wave the parchment.
“A genius! A genius! Oh, Headmistress!”
Minerva could feel a headache beginning. Martha Read reminded her something of Sybil, in that she was rather highly-strung and prone to screeching at loud volume.
“Yes, Martha!” she snapped. Patience is a virtue, chanted her brain piously.
Martha swooped down on her and shoved the parchment in her face. She glimpsed lines of narrow, loopy writing before the text was ripped away, to be held delicately on up-turned palms as though the professor was making some sort of offering to the sky.
“Headmistress! In my hands I now hold… an academic peak!”
There was a pause - Slughorn and Pomona having been stunned into silence, and the rest of the room speechless at the bizarre statement. Minerva gazed from the parchment to Professor Read’s excited face and back again, at a loss.
“An academic peak?” she repeated, carefully.
“Yes!”
“Really?” asked Professor Vector. “I never thought that that was something that one could actually hold, so to speak.”
Hagrid set down his book, scratching his head in obvious confusion. “Beggin’ yer pardon, Professor Read, but I’m afraid I’m not understandin’ yeh.”
“Neither does anyone else,” said Minerva acidly, impatience beginning to break free. “Spit it out, Martha. And please sit down and stop cluttering up the room.”
Martha Read sank down into a chair - but continued to hold the parchment up, gazing skywards with a starstruck expression. “Headmistress,” she whispered. “This academic peak I have here - is none other than the work of a First-Year.”
Pomona snorted. “Then I sincerely doubt that it’s any sort of an academic peak.”
“This essay,” Martha continued reverently, “is a work of genius.”
There was another startled pause. Minerva raised one eyebrow: student’s work had been described as excellent, outstanding and brilliant - and even then, those drooling descriptions were confined to reports and references. Students themselves were sometimes referred to tentatively as bright or talented, on the basis of multiple essays and other pieces of work. To sit in the staff room and declare a student to be a genius was unheard of - especially when said pupil was a First-Year and the evidence was one essay.
“’Genius?’ That’s a very strong word,” squeaked Filius from the other side of the room.
“Unless you are going to explain further-” began Minerva testily.
Martha snapped to attention and brought the essay down to lap-level. “Headmistress, I’m not sure if you were aware, but I set the First-Years an essay in their third lesson on-”
“I was most certainly aware. I believe I urged you not to set it.”
“Yes, well… The essay was on the simple template of any normal Transfiguration spell - known as the Transmutation Matrix, which concerns the-”
“Once upon a time, around about the time when dinosaurs walked the earth, I was the Transfiguration Professor; I’m quite aware of the Transmutation Matrix,” hissed Minerva. She clamped her jaw shut, knowing that if she continued, she would be completely unable to curb her tongue.
“Oh… Oh yes, of course,” said the other woman, flushing. “Well… I only meant for them to do a very basic discussion of the main principles - but this student-” she waved the essay “-this student - oh, Headmistress, I’ve never read anything like it.”
“Please stop gushing and get to the point.”
“Of course, well, this student’s essay - it reads like something out of the Transfiguration Journal!”
“Are you sure they did not simply copy out of it?” suggested Filius gently.
“They can’t have - they explained it from a very neutral standpoint, when most articles in the Journal are biased to one side or the other and nobody’s recently-”
“Forgive me,” said Professor Vector. “But Transfiguration was never my speciality. This …Matrix is a template, correct? How can there be a debate over it?”
“There are many arguments over the actual fundamentals,” Minerva found herself explaining. “It’s very complicated: there are two views on how particles behave during Transfiguration, and then there are many standpoints on whether or not the particles can be manipulated in certain ways… Also, the Matrix fails to explain the why in why does Transfiguration work that way? There are even debates about it in regards to things like death, birth and ageing.”
“Thank Merlin I never took Transfiguration beyond my OWLs,” muttered Slughorn.
“Anyway,” continued Professor Read, “this student covers most of the main debates and actually talked about particles! It’s far beyond Seventh-Year level! I - I confess I don’t understand a good deal of it-”
Slughorn raised his thick eyebrows. “You don’t understand a First-Year’s essay?”
Minerva took a deep, bracing breath. Martha Read was simply silly and deluded; she did not deserve to be shouted at, especially when she honestly believed what she was saying. It was time to be gentle. “I don’t like to suggest it, but it sounds as though this student either copied out of a book on the subject or got someone more knowledgeable than themselves to write it for them.”
Martha’s face fell. “Yes… I suppose that’s always possible,” she said slowly.
“What’s the student’s name?”
“Brian Potter.”
The Headmistress blinked in disappointed surprise - and then scolded herself inside her head. Just because Harry and Ginny were pinnacles of modesty and honesty didn’t necessarily mean that their son was immune from human failings, she berated herself. Such prejudice!
“Let me read it myself, and perhaps it might ring a bell to me and allow me to pin-point the source or whatever he’s copied from.”
“Oh… oh all right then,” said Martha, seeming to deflate like a popped balloon. “I’ll just be - be getting back to my marking, then.”
The door slammed, Pomona and Slughorn resumed arguing and Sybil continued to sniff. Minerva set the essay aside and turned back to Rolanda - only to find that the flying instructor had exited some time before, thoroughly worn down with impatience.
A mere four days into the new school year - and already, there had been trouble.
A bad sign, Minerva thought wearily as she made her way up to the staff room. It certainly did not bode well for the rest of the year when it had taken just two days for three students to be found wandering around the Forbidden Forest by Hagrid - Sixth-Years, no less, who should have known better. Then there had been the recent spat of trouble between Slughorn and Pomona - with the latter claiming that the former had ‘mutilated her prize Tentacula with the base intention of procuring venom for his wretched potions.’ Sybil Trelawney had yet again marched into Minerva’s office to demand Firenze’s immediate ejection from the castle, with the result that the Headmistress had felt very much like ejecting Sybil from the castle. To cap it all, Professor Read, the new Transfiguration teacher, had stubbornly set the First-Years an essay that was quite beyond their capabilities despite multiple objections.
She shook her head; surely it wasn’t all that bad? The Sixth-Years had been unharmed, with the lies simply extending to the idea of ‘some man in the woods’ they’d apparently followed, the prize Tantacula was hardly ‘mutilated’ and Sybil was as a permanent a problem as the drainage; one had to accept it and move on. As for Professor Read - there was no doubt that her own prejudices were interfering there. Perhaps it was because she lived in the past so much, but Professor Read would always be ‘new’ - and what’s more, a usurper of her position. Minerva wondered whether Albus had felt the same when she’d taken over Transfiguration; she hoped not.
The staff room was ominously silent when she entered. Pomona was fuming darkly in an armchair by the fire, a book entitled Repairing Herbological Damage perched conspicuously on her knee, and Slughorn was red in the face and seemed inflated even more than usual by an air of injured self-importance. The room still seemed to echo from the sounds of a heated argument. Trelawney gave an obvious sniff at Minerva’s entry and went back to her marking with a look that said: That woman. She’ll never understand me, the poor abused Seer…
The Headmistress shot her a glare and made her way over the sofa where Rolanda sat. She rarely entered the staff room but when she did, it was usually to see the flying instructor. Rolanda had mumbled something at breakfast about one of the First-Years ‘being uncommonly good on a broom - and the rule was broken once before…’
“Minerva!” said Rolanda, noticing her presence only she sat down next to her. “Glad you’re here - the atmosphere here is terrible-”
“Yes, isn’t it?” said Pomona loudly. “But then, vandalism has never been welcome here at Hogwarts-”
Slughorn mouthed incoherently at the back of the Herbology professor’s head. “These accusations are completely unfounded! My good woman-”
“I am not your good woman, Professor Slughorn,” replied Pomona coldly. “If you needed ingredients, you simply had to ask-”
“I did! Several times! But to suggest that I-”
“And each time, I believe I informed you that it had not yet matured sufficiently-”
“Preposterous! Tentacula venom doesn’t need to mature-”
“Headmistress,” Pomona said sharply. “Professor Slughorn has admitted-”
“Admitted? I have admitted nothing! First you supply me with inaccurate information and then you accuse me-”
Rolanda rolled her eyes and gently put a hand on Minerva‘s shoulder to stop her from standing up to interfere. “Oh ignore them, they’ve been at it all evening.” She leaned forward suddenly, with a serious, excited look.
“Rolanda, if this is about the First-Year-” Minerva began, deciding to stem the adulation before it got out of hand.
To her astonishment, Rolanda waved her hand airily as though batting away a fly. “Never mind about Mr Weasley; he can wait. Listen, I was going up to the Owlery and you’d never believe what I saw!”
“What?”
Doubt crept into her friend’s face. “Well - I think that was what I saw - I only glimpsed it, you see, before it flew away-”
“Spit it out, Rolanda.”
The flying instructor was looking more and more anxious with every second. Minerva felt the brown eyes sweep over her, as if a bombshell was about to be dropped and it was arguable as to whether or not the Headmistress could withstand the impact. “Minerva… I’m not sure whether it was his… it looked like his - but I suppose it could have been-”
The sounds of Slughorn and Pomona’s argument cut off, suddenly, as if all the debate had been was a broadcast on a radio that had been turned off. His. Minerva found herself leaning forward. His? As in… His? A pain shafted down the centre of her chest, down the internal scars left by the Stunners of over a decade before. She took a deep breath-
CRASH.
The door rebounded back off the wall, almost smacking back in the freckled face of Professor Read, who shouted something nobody understood, waving a length of parchment in the air. Minerva found herself in her Animagus form, the shock of the Transfiguration teacher’s entry having forced her transformation and set her fur on end.
Embarassed, the Headmistress shifted back, and sent a disapproving glare in Professor Read’s direction. She turned her head back to Rolanda - but the disturber of the peace was now shrieking something, continuing to wave the parchment.
“A genius! A genius! Oh, Headmistress!”
Minerva could feel a headache beginning. Martha Read reminded her something of Sybil, in that she was rather highly-strung and prone to screeching at loud volume.
“Yes, Martha!” she snapped. Patience is a virtue, chanted her brain piously.
Martha swooped down on her and shoved the parchment in her face. She glimpsed lines of narrow, loopy writing before the text was ripped away, to be held delicately on up-turned palms as though the professor was making some sort of offering to the sky.
“Headmistress! In my hands I now hold… an academic peak!”
There was a pause - Slughorn and Pomona having been stunned into silence, and the rest of the room speechless at the bizarre statement. Minerva gazed from the parchment to Professor Read’s excited face and back again, at a loss.
“An academic peak?” she repeated, carefully.
“Yes!”
“Really?” asked Professor Vector. “I never thought that that was something that one could actually hold, so to speak.”
Hagrid set down his book, scratching his head in obvious confusion. “Beggin’ yer pardon, Professor Read, but I’m afraid I’m not understandin’ yeh.”
“Neither does anyone else,” said Minerva acidly, impatience beginning to break free. “Spit it out, Martha. And please sit down and stop cluttering up the room.”
Martha Read sank down into a chair - but continued to hold the parchment up, gazing skywards with a starstruck expression. “Headmistress,” she whispered. “This academic peak I have here - is none other than the work of a First-Year.”
Pomona snorted. “Then I sincerely doubt that it’s any sort of an academic peak.”
“This essay,” Martha continued reverently, “is a work of genius.”
There was another startled pause. Minerva raised one eyebrow: student’s work had been described as excellent, outstanding and brilliant - and even then, those drooling descriptions were confined to reports and references. Students themselves were sometimes referred to tentatively as bright or talented, on the basis of multiple essays and other pieces of work. To sit in the staff room and declare a student to be a genius was unheard of - especially when said pupil was a First-Year and the evidence was one essay.
“’Genius?’ That’s a very strong word,” squeaked Filius from the other side of the room.
“Unless you are going to explain further-” began Minerva testily.
Martha snapped to attention and brought the essay down to lap-level. “Headmistress, I’m not sure if you were aware, but I set the First-Years an essay in their third lesson on-”
“I was most certainly aware. I believe I urged you not to set it.”
“Yes, well… The essay was on the simple template of any normal Transfiguration spell - known as the Transmutation Matrix, which concerns the-”
“Once upon a time, around about the time when dinosaurs walked the earth, I was the Transfiguration Professor; I’m quite aware of the Transmutation Matrix,” hissed Minerva. She clamped her jaw shut, knowing that if she continued, she would be completely unable to curb her tongue.
“Oh… Oh yes, of course,” said the other woman, flushing. “Well… I only meant for them to do a very basic discussion of the main principles - but this student-” she waved the essay “-this student - oh, Headmistress, I’ve never read anything like it.”
“Please stop gushing and get to the point.”
“Of course, well, this student’s essay - it reads like something out of the Transfiguration Journal!”
“Are you sure they did not simply copy out of it?” suggested Filius gently.
“They can’t have - they explained it from a very neutral standpoint, when most articles in the Journal are biased to one side or the other and nobody’s recently-”
“Forgive me,” said Professor Vector. “But Transfiguration was never my speciality. This …Matrix is a template, correct? How can there be a debate over it?”
“There are many arguments over the actual fundamentals,” Minerva found herself explaining. “It’s very complicated: there are two views on how particles behave during Transfiguration, and then there are many standpoints on whether or not the particles can be manipulated in certain ways… Also, the Matrix fails to explain the why in why does Transfiguration work that way? There are even debates about it in regards to things like death, birth and ageing.”
“Thank Merlin I never took Transfiguration beyond my OWLs,” muttered Slughorn.
“Anyway,” continued Professor Read, “this student covers most of the main debates and actually talked about particles! It’s far beyond Seventh-Year level! I - I confess I don’t understand a good deal of it-”
Slughorn raised his thick eyebrows. “You don’t understand a First-Year’s essay?”
Minerva took a deep, bracing breath. Martha Read was simply silly and deluded; she did not deserve to be shouted at, especially when she honestly believed what she was saying. It was time to be gentle. “I don’t like to suggest it, but it sounds as though this student either copied out of a book on the subject or got someone more knowledgeable than themselves to write it for them.”
Martha’s face fell. “Yes… I suppose that’s always possible,” she said slowly.
“What’s the student’s name?”
“Brian Potter.”
The Headmistress blinked in disappointed surprise - and then scolded herself inside her head. Just because Harry and Ginny were pinnacles of modesty and honesty didn’t necessarily mean that their son was immune from human failings, she berated herself. Such prejudice!
“Let me read it myself, and perhaps it might ring a bell to me and allow me to pin-point the source or whatever he’s copied from.”
“Oh… oh all right then,” said Martha, seeming to deflate like a popped balloon. “I’ll just be - be getting back to my marking, then.”
The door slammed, Pomona and Slughorn resumed arguing and Sybil continued to sniff. Minerva set the essay aside and turned back to Rolanda - only to find that the flying instructor had exited some time before, thoroughly worn down with impatience.
Monday, February 12, 2007
HA 9f: Languish
HIM AGAIN: Chapter 9: Human Intelligence - Languish
Minerva McGonagall watched as Deputy Headmaster Flitwick set the hat upon the stool and let the song wash over her, resting her eyes on the line of bedraggled, soaked First-Years standing nervously near the High Table. Rolanda nudged her and mouthed a name in her ear. She soon found Eric Weasley, the third child of Bill and Fleur, already bearing his father’s rakish air, but he was busy gawping at the Sorting Hat and so didn’t noticed the small smile she aimed at him.
She was about to finally tune into the Sorting Hat’s song when she became aware of the prickling sensation of sitting under a very intense gaze. Her orbs scanned the line again - and found a boy with long untidy auburn hair and large blue eyes, who was giving her such a penetrating look that she was strongly reminded of Moody’s artificial stare that saw through everything.
Minerva expected the boy to look away once he became aware that his stare was being returned - but he did not. Oddly disconcerted, she smiled in what she hoped was a welcoming manner. Brian Potter, whispered her brain, finally matching a name to a face.
The boy’s lips twitched in return. His eyes were wide, his face pale.
People were clapping; the song had ended. Filius cleared his throat and beamed.
“When I call your name, please sit and put on the hat,” he squeaked. “Ainsley, Robert!”
The First-Years began to be be Sorted, walking off to their respective assorted destinies. Minerva found herself waiting for the moment when ‘Potter, Brian’ would be called - and when it was, watched the boy curiously as he strode up to the stool with an unusually confident manner and placed the hat upon his head.
Albus got a glimpse of the Gryffindor table craning eagerly at him before the hat dropped over his eyes. He waited, with the profound sense of the familiar and known all around him, and with Minerva’s smile dominating a greater part of his brain than the issue of the Sorting.
“Well now-” The smooth voice of the hat cut itself off. Albus felt himself revelling in the shock of something that had always previously been frustratingly omniscient.
“By Merlin! You!” said the hat.
Me, he thought back somewhat smugly.
“Alive! And as… Merlin’s beard, Merlin’s beard! Such a thing has never happened! What? Oh, so you’re enjoying my surprise, hmm? I have a good mind to put you in Slytherin or shout the truth to the whole school, Headmaster Dumbledore!”
I would rather you didn’t. It could make things exceptionally difficult.
“Difficult, eh? Well, I must say I’m finding things very interesting at present. It’s rare for me to rest on a mind as old as yours anyway. The things I’m finding…
Please place me.
“Now, now, Albus. Impatience is a virtue in nobody, least of all you - especially when you’ve been incredibly sluggish in realising certain things. Is this your plan, then? To languish away in another life and never tell anybody the truth? Or do you plan to proclaim your affections the next time you get sent to the Headmistress’s office after a carefully obtained detention? Or do you want me to slip it in her ear some time..?”
Albus felt his knuckles crack as he gripped the stool in shock. The hat knew - but no, of course, it had got it all wrong - his affections? Really-
“I thought you’d come to terms with it,” said the hat disapprovingly. “If you wish to delude yourself, then very well. You haven’t planned a thing - which is very unlike you. Your mind has the hallmarks of a brilliant Slytherin, such cunning and resourcefulness…”
I do not believe I’m deluding myself. And-
“That was a rather circumlocutionary thought.”
-I doubt I would like being a Slytherin for seven years.
“No? Yet no prejudice in this head, only old pain. Wondering what’s the matter with Minerva? I’ll let you work it out on your own, armed with your great wisdom and almost supernatural intelligence… You have a honed mind, a beautifully honed mind. There’s Slytherin cunning, Ravenclaw cleverness, Hufflepuff kindness and Gryffindor bravery all in here, all working in union… Hmm, what a decision…”
Thank you.
“Thank me when you’ve sorted your heart out as well as your head.”
I’ve been sitting here for five minutes. I don’t mean to be rude, but-
“‘Yet accidental rudeness occurs alarmingly often. Best say nothing at all, my good man.’ Classic, Albus, simply classic. Such interesting memories you have… I think I concur with my previous decision. That’ll be… GRYFFINDOR!”
Albus took off the hat with a sigh of relief and marched up to Gryffindor table, barely hearing the cheers. He sat down, smiled distractedly at Abigail Lupin, Head Girl, and looked back at the High Table.
Connection sprang between the Headmistress and the boy again, an invisible thread attached their pupils. Brian’s cheeks flushed; Minerva looked away and began talking to Rolanda Hooch. He closed his eyes for a moment, and the Great Hall faded from existence until only Minerva remained.
…Proclaim your affections…
Never; it was impossible.
…Languish away in another life…
He opened his eyes and the brightness of the Great Hall stung them. What other choice did he have?
Minerva McGonagall watched as Deputy Headmaster Flitwick set the hat upon the stool and let the song wash over her, resting her eyes on the line of bedraggled, soaked First-Years standing nervously near the High Table. Rolanda nudged her and mouthed a name in her ear. She soon found Eric Weasley, the third child of Bill and Fleur, already bearing his father’s rakish air, but he was busy gawping at the Sorting Hat and so didn’t noticed the small smile she aimed at him.
She was about to finally tune into the Sorting Hat’s song when she became aware of the prickling sensation of sitting under a very intense gaze. Her orbs scanned the line again - and found a boy with long untidy auburn hair and large blue eyes, who was giving her such a penetrating look that she was strongly reminded of Moody’s artificial stare that saw through everything.
Minerva expected the boy to look away once he became aware that his stare was being returned - but he did not. Oddly disconcerted, she smiled in what she hoped was a welcoming manner. Brian Potter, whispered her brain, finally matching a name to a face.
The boy’s lips twitched in return. His eyes were wide, his face pale.
People were clapping; the song had ended. Filius cleared his throat and beamed.
“When I call your name, please sit and put on the hat,” he squeaked. “Ainsley, Robert!”
The First-Years began to be be Sorted, walking off to their respective assorted destinies. Minerva found herself waiting for the moment when ‘Potter, Brian’ would be called - and when it was, watched the boy curiously as he strode up to the stool with an unusually confident manner and placed the hat upon his head.
Albus got a glimpse of the Gryffindor table craning eagerly at him before the hat dropped over his eyes. He waited, with the profound sense of the familiar and known all around him, and with Minerva’s smile dominating a greater part of his brain than the issue of the Sorting.
“Well now-” The smooth voice of the hat cut itself off. Albus felt himself revelling in the shock of something that had always previously been frustratingly omniscient.
“By Merlin! You!” said the hat.
Me, he thought back somewhat smugly.
“Alive! And as… Merlin’s beard, Merlin’s beard! Such a thing has never happened! What? Oh, so you’re enjoying my surprise, hmm? I have a good mind to put you in Slytherin or shout the truth to the whole school, Headmaster Dumbledore!”
I would rather you didn’t. It could make things exceptionally difficult.
“Difficult, eh? Well, I must say I’m finding things very interesting at present. It’s rare for me to rest on a mind as old as yours anyway. The things I’m finding…
Please place me.
“Now, now, Albus. Impatience is a virtue in nobody, least of all you - especially when you’ve been incredibly sluggish in realising certain things. Is this your plan, then? To languish away in another life and never tell anybody the truth? Or do you plan to proclaim your affections the next time you get sent to the Headmistress’s office after a carefully obtained detention? Or do you want me to slip it in her ear some time..?”
Albus felt his knuckles crack as he gripped the stool in shock. The hat knew - but no, of course, it had got it all wrong - his affections? Really-
“I thought you’d come to terms with it,” said the hat disapprovingly. “If you wish to delude yourself, then very well. You haven’t planned a thing - which is very unlike you. Your mind has the hallmarks of a brilliant Slytherin, such cunning and resourcefulness…”
I do not believe I’m deluding myself. And-
“That was a rather circumlocutionary thought.”
-I doubt I would like being a Slytherin for seven years.
“No? Yet no prejudice in this head, only old pain. Wondering what’s the matter with Minerva? I’ll let you work it out on your own, armed with your great wisdom and almost supernatural intelligence… You have a honed mind, a beautifully honed mind. There’s Slytherin cunning, Ravenclaw cleverness, Hufflepuff kindness and Gryffindor bravery all in here, all working in union… Hmm, what a decision…”
Thank you.
“Thank me when you’ve sorted your heart out as well as your head.”
I’ve been sitting here for five minutes. I don’t mean to be rude, but-
“‘Yet accidental rudeness occurs alarmingly often. Best say nothing at all, my good man.’ Classic, Albus, simply classic. Such interesting memories you have… I think I concur with my previous decision. That’ll be… GRYFFINDOR!”
Albus took off the hat with a sigh of relief and marched up to Gryffindor table, barely hearing the cheers. He sat down, smiled distractedly at Abigail Lupin, Head Girl, and looked back at the High Table.
Connection sprang between the Headmistress and the boy again, an invisible thread attached their pupils. Brian’s cheeks flushed; Minerva looked away and began talking to Rolanda Hooch. He closed his eyes for a moment, and the Great Hall faded from existence until only Minerva remained.
…Proclaim your affections…
Never; it was impossible.
…Languish away in another life…
He opened his eyes and the brightness of the Great Hall stung them. What other choice did he have?
HA 9e: History
HIM AGAIN: Chapter 9: Human Intelligence - History
That boy - that one, with the orange hair and funny glasses - know who he is?
What? Him, sitting next to the window, staring into space?
-He’s Brian Potter. You know, Harry Potter’s son! Ronald Weasley’s nephew!
He was in the papers, wasn’t he - with a full colour family photo album in the middle of the Daily Prophet! It must be awesome, having such a cool family! And being so famous, for doing nothing but being born!
-Tried to say hello to him; just said hi back and then ignored me! And I was staring at him for ages-
-Probably thinks he’s too high and mighty for us-
-Nah, bet he’s sick of it all - must be so annoying, not being able to go outside without getting your picture taken-
-D’you reckon he’s asked his dad about it all? You know, the juicy bits they don’t print in the papers or teach you in History? I bet he has - and his dad’s Chief Auror - so he probably knows more spells and stuff than all of us put together! And he’s in our year!
-Hey - what if he has his dad’s cloak and map? You know - he’s supposed to have an Invisibility Cloak and this special map of Hogwarts that-
-I asked him - and he said yes - so I bet there’ll be a few good pranks played by the end of this year-
-He doesn’t look much like his parents, does he? I mean, his mum’s got orange hair and so has he, but other than that-
-What’s all the excitement, what’s all the fuss? It’s ancient history, it doesn’t matter any more! So his dad’s Chief Auror and destroyed some mouldy old Dark Lord - so what? I wish the papers would get over it. And it’s like with old folks. “During the war-”
-Oh, he’s gone and gone off now! I think you annoyed him; he looked well angry just then-
-Who cares? He was all quiet and odd anyway, I bet he’s screwy. Anyone know what the Sorting Ceremony’s like? Or about any of the Houses? My whole family’s been in Ravenclaw-
-Dunno, but I’ve heard that Gryffindor’s quite…
Albus stood outside the compartment door, fuming. He clenched his young hands into fists and shoved them inside his robes, before setting off to pace up and down the corridor. It wasn’t their fault - how could they understand something that had happened before they born? How could anyone understand anymore?
That boy - that one, with the orange hair and funny glasses - know who he is?
What? Him, sitting next to the window, staring into space?
-He’s Brian Potter. You know, Harry Potter’s son! Ronald Weasley’s nephew!
He was in the papers, wasn’t he - with a full colour family photo album in the middle of the Daily Prophet! It must be awesome, having such a cool family! And being so famous, for doing nothing but being born!
-Tried to say hello to him; just said hi back and then ignored me! And I was staring at him for ages-
-Probably thinks he’s too high and mighty for us-
-Nah, bet he’s sick of it all - must be so annoying, not being able to go outside without getting your picture taken-
-D’you reckon he’s asked his dad about it all? You know, the juicy bits they don’t print in the papers or teach you in History? I bet he has - and his dad’s Chief Auror - so he probably knows more spells and stuff than all of us put together! And he’s in our year!
-Hey - what if he has his dad’s cloak and map? You know - he’s supposed to have an Invisibility Cloak and this special map of Hogwarts that-
-I asked him - and he said yes - so I bet there’ll be a few good pranks played by the end of this year-
-He doesn’t look much like his parents, does he? I mean, his mum’s got orange hair and so has he, but other than that-
-What’s all the excitement, what’s all the fuss? It’s ancient history, it doesn’t matter any more! So his dad’s Chief Auror and destroyed some mouldy old Dark Lord - so what? I wish the papers would get over it. And it’s like with old folks. “During the war-”
-Oh, he’s gone and gone off now! I think you annoyed him; he looked well angry just then-
-Who cares? He was all quiet and odd anyway, I bet he’s screwy. Anyone know what the Sorting Ceremony’s like? Or about any of the Houses? My whole family’s been in Ravenclaw-
-Dunno, but I’ve heard that Gryffindor’s quite…
Albus stood outside the compartment door, fuming. He clenched his young hands into fists and shoved them inside his robes, before setting off to pace up and down the corridor. It wasn’t their fault - how could they understand something that had happened before they born? How could anyone understand anymore?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
